Guest post by Sebastian Zarate
The biodiversity in Paracas National Reserve (La Republica 2020) is tremendous: Approximately 216 species of birds, 36 of mammals, 10 of reptiles, and 168 of fish. A consortium of Spanish and Brazilian firms called Terminal Portuario Paracas (TPP) want to transport and export cooper and zinc concentrates through the Port of San Martin located in the reserve’s buffer zone. In 2014, the Peruvian government transferred the management of this port to TPP (Bartra 2020). In 2016, TPP’s Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) was approved despite multiple objections. To expand the export of minerals, TPP requested an amendment to its EIA in 2018.
Todos por Paracas is a Peruvian non-governmental initiative that aims to raise awareness about the risks that Paracas National Reserve could face if TPP expands its operations. Todos por Paracas aims to place the following public issues in the Peruvian environmental policy agenda: reduction of environmental impacts, protection of fish and wildlife, and stricter government regulation of extractive activities such as mining. The NGO has relied on activism through art and social media was fostered to pressure the Peruvian authorities to reject the 2018 EIA amendments presented by TPP.
Todos por Parcas
Voces de Paracas (Todos por Parcas campaign) highlighted artistic contributions to inform the public about the potential impacts and risks of ore transportation in the reserve’s buffer zone. Illustrators contributed depicting the traits of the species that could be affected by pollution. The goal was to increase the public understanding of conservation through activism as well as to engage and inform Peruvian citizens and decision makers about the risks that may endanger the reserve’s biodiversity. SENACE is the Peruvian authority in charge of accepting or rejecting TPP’s EIA amendments. #SalvemosParacas was used by artists, scientists, politicians, and other stakeholders to encourage SENACE to reject this project.
Example of illustrations used in Voces de Paracas campaign.
Source: Todos por Paracas Facebook page.
Paracas is in danger! The expansion of the port will allow the storing and transportation of mineral concentrate, which puts the biodiversity of Paracas at high risk. Let’s not allow an attack on the biodiversity of the Reserve! ¡#SalvemosParacas! pic.twitter.com/9hK96x098z
— En Movimiento (@enmovimiento_pe) July 13, 2020
In contrast with citizen science projects supervised by professional scientists that coordinate volunteers as research assistants, Todos Por Paracas is not focused on gaining new knowledge, but on spreading knowledge, raising environmental consciousness, shifting media and policy discourse, and driving policy changes. As Kimura & Kinchy mention, deep and active participation in scientific knowledge making does not necessarily enable people to challenge powerful institutions or achieve desired outcomes. In this case, illustrators volunteered their expertise to increase public understanding of biodiversity with the aim of new policy outcomes rather than to further research agendas set by professional experts.
#CitSciChat
The #CitSciChat is a series of Q&A twitter sessions that Caren Cooper started a few years ago. For this session, the panelists below posted responses to questions about Todos por Paracas initiative and sociopolitical context on Twitter with #CitSciChat. The guests have experience in anti-mining mobilization, marine biology and biodiversity, public policy and political ecology, citizen science and science and technology studies. I retweeted their responses from my account (@zarate_vasquez).
a. Luis Romero (@LuisRomeroSN): Sociologist with experience in science and technologies studies in Latin America graduated from National University of San Marcos. He is a graduate student in the National University of Quilmes Science, Technology and Society Program. He has conducted research in gender and science and is focused on the connection between arts and science.
b. Esteli Velia (@litabril): Political scientist and illustrator. She participated in Voces de Paracas campaign. Fellow of the Postgraduate Program on Sustainable Development and Social Inequalities in the Andean Region. She is interested in the limitations of local governance of natural resources around redistributive social and environmental conflicts.
c. Karla Calderon (@karlacalderonma): Peruvian biologist with a master’s in aquatic systems ecology with a focus on artisanal fishery and marine resources management. She is currently the technical manager of the CFI AL-UNDP Coastal Fisheries Initiative Project, which focuses on shell and mangrove crab management in Piura and Tumbes.
d. Tania Ramirez (@TaniaRamirezF): Sociologist with a master’s in environmental development from the Pontifical Catholic University of Peru. Fellow of the Postgraduate Program in Sustainable Development and Social Inequalities in the Andean Region. Founder and member of Eco-Razonar, a feminist political ecology collective. She conducts research on communities and mining in Peru.
This bilingual event took place on Tuesday, November 3 from 16-17 Hrs. ET.
Selected Posts from #CitSciChat
Empezamos en breve! We start soon! #CitSciChat @LuisRomeroSN @litabril @karlacalderonma @TaniaRamirezF #CitSci#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
I am happy to welcome you to my #CitSciChat on public understanding of biodiversity, environmental activism, and art in Peru. I will introduce our topic of discussion and then our panelists. #CitSci#CitizenScience#SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Les doy la bienvenida a mi #CitSciChat sobre participación pública en conservación y recursos naturales, activismo y arte en Perú. Vamos a discutir las controversias sobre Paracas y el rol que @todosporparacas ha venido desempeñando. https://t.co/XUlpedznaH
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Voces de Paracas (@todosporparacas campaign) highlighted artistic contributions to inform about the potential impacts and risks of ore transportation in the reserve’s buffer zone. #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
You can find out more about our #CitSciChat discussion topic this blog post on the @SciStarter webpage: https://t.co/CbTKlkOOVe #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Our first guest is Karla Calderon (@karlacalderonma). She is a Peruvian biologist with a master’s in aquatic systems ecology with a focus on artisanal fishery and marine resources. #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Our second guest is Tania Ramirez (@TaniaRamirezF). She is a Peruvian sociologist with a master’s in environmental development from PUCP. She is founder and member of Eco-Razonar, a feminist political ecology collective. #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Our third guest is Esteli Velia (@litabril). She is a Peruvian political scientist and illustrator. She participated in Voces de Paracas campaign. She is interested in the limitations of local governance of natural resources. #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Finally Luis Romero (@LuisRomeroSN). He is a Peruvian sociologist with experience in science and technologies studies. He is a graduate student in the National University of Quilmes Science, Technology and Society Program. #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Pueden participar en ingles o español, la idea es que se genere debate en torno al rol que desempeña el arte y el activismo en incrementar el conocimiento de la población sobre los riesgos ambientales#CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
In order to manage better our #CitSciChat, I will tweet the question for the panelists using the prefix: Q1, Q2, etc. and the panelists will begin each answer with the prefix: A1, A2, etc. #CitSciChat#SalvemosParacas#CienciaCiudadana
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Q1: Why is the biological diversity of Paracas so important to preserve? Do Peruvians value it? How Paracas is different from other places in terms of natural resources diversity? #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Q2: What are the main characteristics of the endangered species that live in Paracas? What are the possible scenarios if the TPP project goes forward? #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
I want to thank @CoopSciScoop and @SciStarter for their support on this #CitSciChat.#SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Q3: Which tools do you think are important to raise awareness about endangered species and natural reserves in Peru? #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
#CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas https://t.co/pEBccxV2lr
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
The Peruvian goverment was interested in protecting Paracas since 1975. In 1992 the United Nations recognized its biodiversity.#CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas https://t.co/pE03SSRlT2
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Q4: What is the legacy of mining and the extractive industry in Peru? Have the power relationships between communities, government and private companies changed over time? #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Q5: How the Peruvian antimining movement evolved, and what role does it play in recent environmental conflicts? Do you think that it played a similar role the case of Paracas? #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
#CitSciChat#SalvemosParacas#CienciaCiudadana https://t.co/RCSTkzx7Yq
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Q6: How did Todos Por Parcas started? Why it was deemed necessary to include art and illustrators to raise awareness? #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Q7: Do you think that Voces Por Paracas (Todos por Parcas campaign) is an effective public engagement initiative? #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
#CitSciChat#SalvemosParacas#CienciaCiudadana https://t.co/bOyNFjY4Vm
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Ya comenzamos con el #CitSciChat participación ciudadana en la defensa de la Reserva de Paracas! Dirigido por @zarate_vasquez y @SciStarter #citizenscience #salvemosparacas https://t.co/36k43W9aql
— Estelí Vela (@litabril) November 3, 2020
#CitSciChat#SalvemosParacas#CienciaCiudadana https://t.co/9lawQRxisc
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Q8: What do you think are the opportunities and limitations of art to increase public engagement in conservation? #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Interesting quote about environmental protection.#CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas https://t.co/XUJ35oPy4b
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Q9: Do you think art is an “effective” first step to increase visibility of a public issue? How other type of art (eg. Documentaries) can inform natural resource policies reforms? #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Very interesting comparison between rural and urban mobilizations against mining in Peru. #CitSciChat#SalvemosParacas#CienciaCiudadana https://t.co/lFuwwG42z0
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Q10: What have been the main issues to popularize science in Peru? Do you think that art increases science cultural value? Would scientific institutions benefit from this? #CitSciChat #SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Interesting insights about symbolic power of environmental claims and raising awareness based on gastronomy and historical symbols. I wonder if that happens in other countries in Latin America. @TaniaRamirezF#CitSciChat#SalvemosParacas#CienciaCiudadana https://t.co/Y3l02AyWGw
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Arts appeal to the senses and can engage the public based on emotions. Art is another form of recreation of reality according to @LuisRomeroSN #CitSciChat#SalvemosParacas#CienciaCiudadana https://t.co/yChFP21yUp
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
I miss the Peruvian lemon 🙁 https://t.co/xi7eadZ7ab
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
It seems like activism and art have a long history, since the invention of the printing press. https://t.co/jUuZF9ShEw
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
How we can translate the science fair efforts of the Peruvian Government into popularization of science program that are sustained?#CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas https://t.co/ofz1U4XgbD
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
I really want to thank all of our panelists today @karlacalderonma @TaniaRamirezF @litabril and @LuisRomeroSN for their incredible contributions. Feel free to keep comenting and engaging with this discussion.#CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Muchas gracias! @SciStarter #CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas https://t.co/zF30AabzVJ
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
La vocacion cientifica es un tema clave que deberia ser mas explorado y trabajado, de la mano con politicas que puedan fortalecer la institucionalidad de la ciencia en Peru.#CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas https://t.co/jfHRVJXUB8
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
I really like the idea of how in quarantine illustration can be a vehicle for collective action as well as medium of sharing ideas and expressing ourselves in the virtual world.#CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas https://t.co/ec0kJkXKKA
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
The challenge could be to generate spaces in which science could interact more with art. @LuisRomeroSN do you think that science has issues generating empathy? https://t.co/lVUUleTWm0
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Hay muchos estudiantes de provincias que siempre han estado participando de las ferias de @ConcytecPeru por mucho tiempo con proyectos muy interesantes.#CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas https://t.co/QFyyvUH7Ua
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Creo que eso motivaria a iniciativias interdisciplinarias que puedan pensar y trabajar en proyectos en estos temas en Peru.#CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas https://t.co/nP7bvvuvHm
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020
Interesante esa idea de que el arte puede alinear, o sea que puede cohesionar diferentes puntos de vista e ideas.#CitSciChat#CienciaCiudadana#SalvemosParacas https://t.co/TIbh1yja35
— Sebastián Zárate (@zarate_vasquez) November 3, 2020